The Ultimate Sanibel Island Shopping Guide

As the Island continues to recover, there are many different restaurants, retail stores, and other businesses that are opening back up. While we’ve personally confirmed that all of these businesses are back open, it’s a good idea to call ahead to confirm that they are open during their normal operating hours before you head out! Supporting and shopping at local businesses helps keep our community vibrant and a great place to live and visit.  

Dresses in window

Artwork and More 

Sanibel Island and Captiva Island are vibrant places for art and culture, and we are privileged to have many local artists that live on the Island. Some of the best local galleries and art-focused places for shopping include: 

  • Rachel Pierce Art Gallery 

Rachel Pierce creates gorgeous pieces, and you can purchase both originals and prints in her Art Gallery. Additionally, her new Lighthouse Jewelry collection helps support Rachel’s rebuild after Hurricane Ian.   

  • Sanibel Art and Frame 

If you pick up gorgeous artwork on Sanibel Island and need it framed or want to find other pieces from local artists, look no further than Sanibel Art and Frame.  

  • BIG ARTS Gift Shop 

The BIG ARTS Gift Shop is a unique arts complex with plenty of opportunities to have fun and go shopping, including music, galleries, a gift shop, and live performances. At the gift shop, you can pick up pottery, handcrafted jewelry, and other keepsakes.  

  • Tower Gallery Artist Cooperative 

Tower Gallery Artist Cooperative is a unique gallery with over 23 local artists of all kinds. There are pieces available in many mediums, including watercolor, acrylic, oil, glass, and metal.  

  • Jungle Drums Gallery 

The Jungle Drums Gallery is a unique experience centered around wildlife art, including fine jewelry made by local artisans and large bronze sculptures that make a statement.  

Gift Shops 

When you come to visit us on Sanibel and Captiva Islands, you should never go home empty-handed! There are plenty of unique gift shops for all of your shopping needs.  

  • Traders Restaurant and Gift Shop  

Traders Restaurant and Gift Shop is now open again. Since 1998, they have been an island favorite. The gift shop includes tchotchkes, books, shirts, and even gift cards so that you can visit again! 

  • Tarpon Bay Explorers Gift & Nature Shop 

The Nature Gift Shop at Tarpon Bay Explorers is an amazing nature-themed gift shop. There is plenty to choose from, including nautical gifts, fishing supplies, t-shirts, hats, toys, jewelry, and home accessories.  

  • CROW Gift Shop 

The Clinic for the Rehabilitation of Wildlife (CROW) has a gift shop that gives back! Everything you purchase supports their wildlife rehabilitation efforts.  

  • The Sanibel Community House 

The Community House supports everyone on Sanibel Island, and the gift shop is a wonderful place to pick up local apparel, culinary treats, jewelry, and local art. All proceeds support the Community House.  

  • Barracudas 

Barracudas is a Captiva gift shop. They make it easy to choose souvenirs, as well as to pick up sunscreen and everything that you need for a great day at the beach.  

  •  Beach Stuff 

As the name indicates, Beach Stuff has you covered for gifts, souvenirs, beachwear, beach toys, supplies, and more.  

Traditional Retail 

Whether you forgot something in your suitcase or you’re looking to enjoy Island fashions once you’re already home, there are multiple clothing, shoe, and home goods stores to enjoy.  

  • Footloose H2O Outfitters 

Footloose H2O Outfitters is a great place to head for stylish and comfortable shoes, in addition to other beachwear like swimsuits, sunglasses, accessories, and apparel.  

  • The Gold Parrot 

The Gold Parrot offers unique and high-quality pieces that you can’t just find anywhere. They offer women’s clothing, men’s clothing, kid’s items, home goods, timepieces, luggage and bags, sunglasses, beauty supplies, beach goods, and more.  

  • Nanny’s of Sanibel 

Nanny’s of Sanibel is a children’s store with charming boutique clothing, swimwear, accessories, toys, and plushies.  

Other 

Sanibel Island has other shopping establishments as well to meet your needs.  

  • Forever Green Ace Hardware 

Need supplies or hardware? Forever Green Ace Hardware has you covered!  

  • Whitney’s Bait & Tackle 

Whitney’s Bait & Tackle is a favorite for fishing lessons, but they also offer everything you need to enjoy time on the water and in the water. If you need fishing gear or tackle that they don’t have in stock, they’ll even order it for you!  

  • Sea Oats Day Spa 

The Sea Oats Day Spa is a lovely option to relax and decompress. They offer body waxing, facials, hair care, manicures, pedicures, and massage.  

Contact Kingfisher Vacation Rentals to Learn More about Sanibel Island Properties 

At Kingfisher Vacation Rentals we choose vacation rentals over hotels every time! We are actively open and assisting owners every day with their recovery process. We’re also ready to bring new properties into our award-winning program. If you are interested in discussing how our unmatched marketing approach and comprehensive owner services will benefit you, call today! For more information about Sanibel and Captiva, contact our team, email us at info@gokingfisher.com, stop by our Captiva office or give us a call today at 239-472-2100.